Hydrogen Water vs Alkaline Water

Hydrogen Tablets vs Alkaline Water: What’s Better for Your Health?



In the world of wellness drinks, two trends have stood out in recent years: hydrogen water and alkaline water. Both promise health benefits beyond regular H2O, and it’s easy to get them mixed up. If you’re wondering how hydrogen tablets (which create hydrogen water) compare to alkaline water for your health, you’re in the right place. In this post, we’ll break down the differences, benefits, and downsides of each. By the end, you’ll see why molecular hydrogen tablets like HydroTabs are gaining an edge as a smarter choice for health-conscious New Zealanders.



Different Waters: Hydrogen vs. Alkaline



First, let’s clarify what each term means:


  • Hydrogen Water – This is water infused with extra hydrogen gas (H2). It’s created either by using an electrolysis device or simply dropping a hydrogen tablet into water. The key feature is the dissolved hydrogen molecules, which act as antioxidants in your body. Importantly, adding hydrogen gas does not change the water’s pH; hydrogen water can be neutral pH and still contain a high concentration of H2.
  • Alkaline Water – This is water with a higher pH level than plain water. Normal water has pH ~7 (neutral). Alkaline water is usually pH 8–9, achieved by adding minerals (like calcium, magnesium) or using a water ionizer machine. It’s sometimes called ionized water. The idea is that this less acidic water can help neutralize excess acidity in the body. However, just because water is alkaline doesn’t mean it contains molecular hydrogen – in fact, many alkaline waters have zero hydrogen gas unless produced by certain ionizers.



In short, hydrogen water focuses on adding H2 gas for therapeutic benefit, while alkaline water focuses on raising pH. They are not the same thing. You can have alkaline water with no hydrogen, and you can have hydrogen water that isn’t alkaline. (Some fancy machines produce hydrogen-rich alkaline water, which does both, but we’ll get to that nuance.)


Here’s a quick comparison of the basics:


  • Composition: Hydrogen water contains millions of dissolved hydrogen molecules but has roughly the same mineral content and pH as the source water. Alkaline water contains added minerals to increase pH, but may not contain any hydrogen gas .
  • Taste: Hydrogen water tastes like normal water (no noticeable change) . Alkaline water can taste slightly different – some describe it as smoother, others notice a subtle mineral or metallic taste, especially if the pH is very high.
  • Mechanism in the Body: Hydrogen from hydrogen water can disperse into your cells and act as an antioxidant and cell-signaling modulator. In contrast, alkaline water’s main proposed mechanism is to neutralize stomach/body acidity. But keep in mind, your body tightly regulates internal pH through breathing and kidney function, so changing your overall blood pH by drinking alkaline water is nearly impossible (your stomach acid will neutralize most of it) .



Now, let’s talk benefits – where hydrogen water and alkaline water claims overlap, and where they differ.



Health Benefits: H

2

vs High pH



Hydrogen Water Benefits: As we’ve detailed in our “7 Proven Benefits of Hydrogen Water” article, hydrogen water has a range of well-researched health benefits:


  • It’s a potent antioxidant (fighting oxidative stress) and has anti-inflammatory effects .
  • It may improve athletic performance and recovery, reducing fatigue and lactic acid build-up .
  • It supports metabolic health, with studies showing improved cholesterol and reduced blood sugar in some cases .
  • It can benefit the cardiovascular system (small studies saw reduced symptoms in heart disease patients) .
  • It potentially offers neuroprotection and cognitive benefits, and even helps skin health via its antioxidant action .



These benefits come from hydrogen’s role at the cellular level. When you drink hydrogen-rich water, the H2 molecules circulate and can enter cells freely (hydrogen is the smallest molecule). They help neutralize harmful radicals and may signal the body to boost its own antioxidant defenses . This can lead to reduced inflammation, better cell energy production, and improved function across various organs.


Alkaline Water Benefits: Alkaline water’s supposed benefits are often stated by its proponents, though scientific evidence is more limited:


  • Improved Hydration: Some believe alkaline water hydrates better or faster. There was one study with 100 adults that found alkaline water might be more hydrating post-exercise, but results aren’t widely replicated. Overall, staying hydrated (with any water) is what’s important . Many people, like one reviewer at HydroPitcher, report no significant difference in hydration between alkaline and hydrogen water .
  • Acid Reflux Relief: This is a more concrete benefit. A pH ~8.8 alkaline water can neutralize pepsin (an acid enzyme) and provide temporary relief from heartburn or acid reflux symptoms . In fact, Harvard Health acknowledges that alkaline water might soothe reflux, albeit briefly . It’s not a cure for GERD, but it can act like a mild antacid.
  • Mineral Supplementation: Alkaline water contains minerals like calcium, magnesium, potassium (depending on how it’s made). These contribute to daily intake – though you can get the same from diet or a regular mineral water. Unless you’re mineral deficient, this isn’t a huge factor.
  • Other Claims (Weight loss, Detox, etc.): You might hear that alkaline water boosts metabolism, slows aging, or “flushes toxins.” These claims are not well-supported by clinical research. Any weight loss from alkaline water is likely due to better hydration and possibly replacing sugary drinks. The body’s main detox organs (liver, kidneys) handle “toxins” regardless of water pH.



What Science Says: Overall, mainstream experts like the Mayo Clinic and Harvard Medical School say there’s no proven benefit of alkaline water for general health over plain water . Your body regulates its pH very effectively; if you drink something very alkaline, your stomach acid neutralizes it, and your blood pH remains constant. Only in specific situations (like acid reflux, or extreme dehydration scenarios) might alkaline water show a benefit, and even then, conventional solutions often work better (e.g., standard rehydration or antacids) .


In contrast, hydrogen water’s benefits are backed by numerous studies. It’s a newer field, but research has been largely positive and continues to grow. There’s evidence from clinical trials that hydrogen water can reduce oxidative stress in patients after radiation therapy (improving their quality of life) , improve exercise recovery, and even help manage conditions like metabolic syndrome . It’s not about changing pH; it’s about adding a therapeutic molecule (H2) that our bodies seem to use beneficially.



Ease of Use and Cost



Practicality matters. How do hydrogen tablets vs alkaline water stack up in everyday use?


  • Using Hydrogen Tablets: Extremely easy. You carry a small tube of tablets, drop one in a glass or bottle of water, wait about 1-2 minutes for it to dissolve and fizz, then drink. There’s no bulky equipment. You can do it at home, at work, or on the go. Each tablet like HydroTabs yields a high concentration of hydrogen (up to ~10 ppm in 500 mL) , which is a potent dose compared to other methods. Cost-wise, hydrogen tablets are affordable – roughly a few NZ dollars per day (often less). For example, a bottle of 60 HydroTabs tablets costs $45 NZD, which comes out to $0.75 per serving of hydrogen water. That’s cheaper than a bottle of kombucha or most fancy drinks!
  • Getting Alkaline Water: There are a few ways:
    • Buy bottled alkaline water: This is the simplest but can get expensive ($3–$5 per liter typically, if imported). Also, it’s not eco-friendly to buy lots of plastic bottles.
    • Use an alkaline filter or jug: Some water filter pitchers claim to alkalize water via mineral cartridges. These are moderately priced but may not produce highly alkaline water and need regular filter replacements.
    • Buy a water ionizer machine: These devices attach to your tap and electrically ionize water to make it alkaline (and sometimes hydrogen-rich). High-quality ionizers can cost thousands of dollars. They also require maintenance (cleaning electrodes, replacing filters). While they do produce alkaline water on demand, the upfront cost is a barrier for many.

  • In terms of ease, bottled or filtered alkaline water is straightforward (just drink), but expensive if used daily. Ionizers are a one-time investment but require installation and know-how. And if you’re traveling or at the office, you can’t easily lug your ionizer with you.



From a cost-benefit perspective, hydrogen tablets clearly offer more bang for your buck. You get a clinically significant dose of hydrogen (with its antioxidant benefits) cheaply and portably. Alkaline water might cost you more in the long run, especially if you invest in equipment or constantly buy bottles, and the health payoff is not as evident.



Potential Downsides



No wellness choice is complete without considering any downsides or risks:


  • Hydrogen Water Downsides: Honestly, there aren’t many. Hydrogen gas is non-toxic and excess H2 just leaves your body naturally. The main caution is that hydrogen tablets should be used as directed (dissolve in water, don’t swallow the tablet directly or you’ll have some burpy discomfort!). Also, you want to drink the water soon after dissolving the tablet, because hydrogen gas will slowly escape – it doesn’t stay in the water for long. In terms of safety, studies have reported no significant adverse effects of hydrogen water even at high doses. Just be aware that if you seal it in a tight bottle right after dropping a tablet, pressure can build from the hydrogen gas; it’s best to dissolve in an open container or a bottle with the lid off, then close it after it’s dissolved if you need to carry it.
  • Alkaline Water Downsides: Alkaline water is generally safe for most people in moderate amounts, but there are a few considerations:
    • It can have a bitter taste at higher pH (>9), which some find unpleasant .
    • If you overdo extremely alkaline water and also take certain medications (like proton pump inhibitors for acid reflux), you might mess with your stomach’s natural acidity too much. In rare cases, too much alkaline water could lead to an alkalosis imbalance, especially if you have kidney issues .
    • By neutralizing stomach acid, alkaline water could impair digestion of proteins and absorption of nutrients if taken in large quantities with meals – your stomach acid is there for a reason (to digest food and kill bacteria). So chugging high-pH water all day long isn’t advisable.
    • It doesn’t address the root causes of most health issues. Some people might use alkaline water as a crutch while ignoring diet or medical care, which is not good. For example, if you have acid reflux disease, drinking alkaline water might ease symptoms but you still need to fix the underlying issue (diet changes, etc.).



In comparison, hydrogen water is more targeted (antioxidant) and doesn’t fundamentally alter your stomach chemistry.



The Verdict: Which Is Better?



When it comes to overall health benefits, scientific backing, and practical use, hydrogen water comes out on top. Here’s why:


  • Stronger Evidence: Hydrogen water has demonstrated benefits in scientific studies for a variety of health aspects (from inflammation to endurance) . Alkaline water’s benefits remain mostly speculative or limited to niche cases like acid reflux.
  • Body’s Balance: Hydrogen works with your body’s natural processes (helping antioxidants, reducing oxidative stress). Alkaline water attempts to artificially shift pH, which your body will counteract quickly . Essentially, hydrogen addresses the oxidative stress that actually contributes to aging and disease, whereas alkaline addresses an “acidity” problem that for most people doesn’t really exist (your blood isn’t too acidic in normal circumstances).
  • Ease and Cost: Popping a hydrogen tablet in water is easier and cheaper than managing an alkaline water regimen (unless you’re fine with plain tap water + maybe an antacid for heartburn). If you’re going to invest in a daily health drink, hydrogen tablets give you more value and flexibility.
  • Compatibility: You can add hydrogen to any drinking water – filtered, tap, mineral – and still keep those water’s minerals. With alkaline, if you already have mineral water you might be duplicating effort, or if you have filtered pure water, you need to add minerals. Hydrogen water doesn’t conflict; you could even have mildly alkaline water and add hydrogen to it for a combined effect if you wanted.



Many experts now believe that the benefits people ascribed to alkaline ionizer machines were actually due to the hydrogen gas those machines also produced. Modern water ionizers electrolyze water, which both splits water into high-pH/low-pH streams and generates some hydrogen gas. It turns out the hydrogen gas may have been the real star delivering benefits, not the alkalinity. This is supported by the fact that high-end ionizers tout their hydrogen ppm output nowadays . So why pay $3,000 for an ionizer to get hydrogen water (with some alkalinity as side effect) when you can just drop a high-purity hydrogen tablet in your glass?



Conclusion: Choose What’s Right for You



If you’re primarily looking for health and wellness benefits, hydrogen water via quality tablets is likely the better choice. It has reputable science on its side and addresses common issues like oxidative stress and inflammation that affect everyone. HydroTabs hydrogen tablets, for instance, provide a convenient way to get those benefits – you can easily incorporate them into your daily routine (morning, post-workout, or whenever) without hassle.


Alkaline water isn’t useless – if you suffer from occasional acid reflux, having a glass of alkaline water might help your symptoms. And staying hydrated with any water is vital for health. But as a daily health strategy, alkaline water falls short of the hype.


For New Zealand readers specifically, consider what’s accessible: HydroTabs are available in NZ, giving you an easy supply of hydrogen tablets. On the other hand, alkaline water products in NZ might be imported or expensive, and tap water in NZ is generally high quality and not overly acidic to begin with.


In summary: Hydrogen water and alkaline water have different purposes. Alkaline water’s main selling point is balancing pH (which your body already does well, except in specific cases), whereas hydrogen water’s selling point is delivering a proven antioxidant boost to your body’s natural defenses. When choosing what to drink for better health, the smart money is on hydrogen-rich water.



Ready to make the switch?



If you want to experience the benefits of hydrogen water firsthand, it’s easy to start. Grab a pack of HydroTabs hydrogen tablets and try a two-week experiment: replace your usual water with hydrogen water and see how you feel. Many notice improvements in energy, recovery and overall wellness. Plus, you’re not giving up anything – you’re still drinking water, just a better version of it!


Why not give it a go? Upgrade your hydration today: Buy HydroTabs Hydrogen Tablets in NZ and enjoy the science-backed advantages of hydrogen water. Your body will thank you for the extra boost!

 

Back to blog